Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Known Dangerous Parts for Judging

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Known Dangerous Parts for Judging

    This question stems from the other thread about reusing an original wiring harness for competition. Gary Karr brought up the point that I had mentioned about an old original harness being a fire hazard. Are fine point cars forced to use original parts for judging, even though they can be a life threatening item? Two items that come to mind at this moment are the fan blade and the wiring harnesses. I realize that each may be an overall small deduction, but who wants to lose any points. Since this seems to be the case, can someone help me understand why.
    3 ~ Tudor's
    Henry Ford said
    "It's all nuts and bolts"


    Mitch's Auto Service ctr

  • #2
    The standard states to the best of the clubs ability how the car rolled off the line. yes there are exceptions,points of contention etc., but it is the best information available. there is no requirement that any of it is followed.. except the 13 (14?) Points required for blue point judging. don't want to old wiring, dont. don't want an original fan, don't. points will be deducted. move on.

    A well done car with minimal repop will score in the 300s-360. nothing to be ashamed of. 400 point are doable with more effort.

    Take the standards, look closely at your car, if you are honesty with the evaluation you will have a very good idea of where you will score.

    Remember the vehicles are scored against the standards, not each other. all cars start with 500 points.

    When I was on the mafca jsc, I got tired of hearing about unsafe fans. I recommended changing the original fan requirement to "metal two blade propeller fan as original. Reproduction fans would have a point deduction". this was accepted by both clubs with modification. it had zero effect on the number of fine point cars entered. so the complaint wasn't about the required original fan, but was an excuse not to enter fine point.
    Ymmv
    http://jmodela.coffeecup.com

    Comment


    • #3
      I do realize what the manual requires and the point deductions that will be taken if it is not followed. My concern was bodily injury or loss of property VS points loss. As Gary stated he hoped not to find his car fried one day. As with anything sometimes an incident is what it takes to change things.
      Thanks for your response
      3 ~ Tudor's
      Henry Ford said
      "It's all nuts and bolts"


      Mitch's Auto Service ctr

      Comment


      • #4
        I've been thinking (dangerous). many times I've heard 'it's my car, I'll build it my way'. the standards are just that, a written standard of how the car was built. it does not state that you have to do it that way. at the same time, you can't change the past. The standards are a recorded history. Allowing full points for modern wiring, aluminum fans, reproduction rubber parts, fan belts, batteries, on & on is unfair to the Marcos, Garys, and previous high point restorers.
        I know that I won't have an original battery, wiring, and muffler. I also know that I will have 3 to 6 points removed. if I was of the opinion that the fan I have wasn't safe, I wouldn't use it, and would have more points deducted. i don't want someone else saying I have to use it or I can't use it. still if thats all the points deducted, its a 490 point car. im good with that. it is my decision. My car, built my way. Clubs arent and shouldn't be involved.

        I have enough problems worrying about myself, I don't want to take on others worries. I was going to join a black powder 'club' one time. went to the range, and saw a guy that had two empty beers and half of another on his bench, pouring pyrodex out of the can down the hot barrel of a hawken with a cigarette dangling from his lips. I turned on my heel and didn't go back. His gun, his way. I wouldn't do it that way but it's none of my business...

        Ymmv
        http://jmodela.coffeecup.com

        Comment


        • BNCHIEF
          BNCHIEF commented
          Editing a comment
          That guy would be off our range in a heartbeat.

      • #5
        I believe that the fuse for safety is allowed in fine point judging with no deductions. The aluminum fan is also allowed but with a small deduction . Norm

        Comment


        • Mark Maron
          Mark Maron commented
          Editing a comment
          Actually all safety items are allowed in fine point if done tastefully...

        • BNCHIEF
          BNCHIEF commented
          Editing a comment
          Mitch you will now have to work on your car in Val's dining room.

      • #6
        I put up a good original fan several years ago. I had another one on a B waterpump, but in my attempt to remove it from the shaft the pulley bent. My bad, it was siezed to the shaft much worse than I anticipated. As for wiring I would take the point deductions. Rod
        "Much of the social history of the Western world, over the past three decades, has been a history of replacing what worked with what sounded good." Thomas Sowell

        Comment


        • #7
          A Model A will NEVER-NEVER-NEVER be as it was on the SHOWROOM FLOOR!!!!----Just WISHFUL THINKING
          KDad LAFFING:rolling---(Gotta' go "P")

          Comment


          • #8
            May never be as on the showroom floor...but that makes a great goal.
            http://jmodela.coffeecup.com

            Comment


            • #9
              Doc K once told me it doesn’t need to be old, just has to fool a judge.....

              Comment

              Related Topics

              Collapse

              • ronnaab
                Judging Standards
                by ronnaab
                Just starting to review my Judging Sheets from Fine Point Judging @ Branson. Can't say that I am to impressed with the knowledge of the judges.
                Standards show deduct 2 points for white walls, my score sheet deducted 20 points. Tools had several points deducted for wrong tire pump, wrong jack handle etc. Same tools were judged 2 different times with a different car (same year) and received full...
                09-26-2018, 11:46 PM
              • Great Lakes Greg
                A good car for fine point restoration
                by Great Lakes Greg
                Greetings, My first post here having migrated over from ******** for something new and to get away from "what kind of oil should I use".
                I have just purchased a rust free Special Coupe that was last registered in 1961. It is a time capsule with about 90% of it's original parts intact. If not for an ugly blue repaint, I would register it in original class in Dearborn next year. I did...
                10-14-2018, 06:24 PM
              • Bill G
                Stock style distributor points
                by Bill G
                Do any of the vendors have stock-style points that actually line up with the point block?

                I am struggling here. It seems that the only combination of upper plate, point block and point arm is to use original of each. The issue there is that the original point block cracked, and the original points are well worn and the spring is a lot weaker than the newer replacements. I would think...
                02-11-2020, 02:13 PM
              • Jwmckenzie
                Points and Condenser
                by Jwmckenzie
                I have run both original points and condenser setups as well as modern points and condensers mounted on the upper plate. I "think" the car sounds better at idle with original points. What is your preference.
                Original Points and Condenser
                76.47%
                26
                Condenser and Points mounted on the upper plate
                20.59%
                7
                Electronic Ignition of some sort
                2.94%
                1
                05-20-2018, 12:48 PM
              • Mitch
                Fine Point Judging Info
                by Mitch
                FINE POINT JUDGING

                Taken from the MARC website:


                MARC was formed in 1952 with the purpose to “encourage its members to acquire, preserve, restore, exhibit, and make use of the Model “A” Ford vehicle, model years 1928 through 1931, and all things pertaining to the Ford Model “A,” and to promote the introduction of ideas and fellowship among MARC members.”...
                08-20-2019, 06:30 AM
              • Roadster Rich
                Rebuilding Lesson Learned
                by Roadster Rich
                I have stated my story before on this site. My 1930 Roadster was purchased new by my grandfather. My dad pulled it into a field on his new property in VT in 1955. In 1966 I pulled it out of the field and started the rebuild then used it from 1968 to today.

                Well I entered into a large car show here in FL. On the judging, when they were done with my car I asked about what they thought....
                03-04-2020, 08:34 AM
              • Captndan
                Points
                by Captndan
                Did a search but came up empty. Where to get good points? Need them now not in a week.
                11-02-2018, 07:04 AM
              • Great Lakes Greg
                Fine point deductions
                by Great Lakes Greg
                Is there a score sheet available for the fine point judging that discloses the point allocations? It would be helpful to have this so I can pick my battles....
                01-17-2021, 02:53 PM
              • A29tudor
                Points
                by A29tudor
                Any one know the thread pitch of the adjustable point on the stock points assy?...
                12-27-2019, 10:06 PM
              • Jim Mason
                dropping semigloss?
                by Jim Mason
                I've been thinking about Mark's comment that he suggested to the JSC to drop the undercarriage semi gloss spec to make the restoration easier.

                Is the current gloss levels (satin, semi gloss, gloss) documented, or is it based on observations of low mile originals, or is it arbitrary?

                Same questions on the dropping the semi gloss?

                If the current standard is not...
                09-11-2021, 07:34 AM
              Working...
              X