Welcome to the Model A Forums

General Discussion
See more
See less

Reasonable Expectations on a Sedan Roof (--revisited topic)

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #26
    What to do?

    PO did full restoration some 20+ years ago. Paint is showing age with chips, cracks, rust bubbling, fade and rough areas. Not interested in effort or expense to do it right, now. Perhaps I will have time in a decade to make it fresh for the century celebration.

    However, I do not want it to get too bad between now and then.

    The roof is in good shape except for the Hideum welting having rotten thread and it separating. Looks like PO hit a few spots with sealant on exterior.

    How hard is it to replace just the welt? And, how much more to do the top?

    The interior is in great shape so I do not want to mess it up.

    As a minimum, I am thinking of removing welt, reseal, tape off and paint, then install new welt.

    What do you think?


    • #27
      Brent: If I was paying you what I think you're getting for a complete restoration I would EXPECT the roof NOT to leak ! ! !
      Paul in CT


      • #28
        Never did a top, but I was looking at how they seal up stuff on boats not long ago.

        I suggest a visit to a boat yard or marine place and ask around about what they use.

        They make some sealers that go between fittings and the hull that keep water out. It looks like a tape of sorts. They also point out for a better seal when you drill holes put a little counter sink so the sealer has a place to go.


        • #29
          2 words.."DRIP CHECK" use it all the time and it works great..Seals, primed and painted what ever color you want...


          • BNCHIEF
            BNCHIEF commented
            Editing a comment
            Please elaborate Mark you have my attention.

        • #30
          Forgot to mention that most of the closed cars were designed to drain water, especially the windows,doors and trunks had weep holes. The '27 Chrysler posted earlier has mohair interior and surprisingly no stains at the top headliner. Most of the sealants back in the day were oil (alkyd), alcohol, or asphalt based, and zinc chromate primer (can be toxic) is a good primer for aluminum moldings. As stated, and having spent decades in the construction industry, today's sealants are complex chemistry and designed for specific applications and materials compatibility.Most of the common big box store sealants are designed to be used with foam backing rods in joints, so automotive types may be better suited , available from commercial auto body paint suppliers, etc. The vendors sell a model A club's replacing Roofs videos with some good techniques on how to improve closed car roofs performance while maintaining the stock appearance.
          Last edited by plyfor; 06-14-2018, 02:11 PM.


          Related Topics


          • Bikerider58
            Roof welt and sealing
            The coupe was restored 20+ yrs ago. Garage kept, so the cover looks okay with no cracking. However, the thread in the Hidem welt has rotted away and the cord is separating. The interior is fine with...
            06-15-2018, 12:09 PM
          • Art Ebeling
            Vickie roof
            Art Ebeling
            This is installing the roof on my 31 Victoria today and yesterday and the day before.... What a tedious job, The moldings were formed first by securing in the groove in the body one loose nail at...
            This is installing the roof and moldings today.  The moldings were shaped first and then nailed down.  It has been a tedious procedure.
            08-17-2017, 05:31 PM
          • Mickey
            Top of coupe
            Can you replace the wood in the roof of the coupe without removing the metal panels on the top sides. I know the front metal needs to come off and I assume probably the headliner. The top was leaking...
            08-29-2018, 08:08 PM
          • Farmputzer
            Top molding nails
            I'm installing the original top molding on my 30 Murray town sedan (155C). It is aluminum 'exposed nail' molding. It would seem that the nails used should be doomed, not ftat. Any comments? Is there a...
            05-25-2018, 10:00 AM
          • Atlasboy
            Putting a new Top on a Cabriolet
            I can’t find a local Convertible Top installer , so I think I will put a new Top on my Model A Cabriolet myself.
            The present Top was installed in 1950 according to the former owner of the Car,...
            09-29-2018, 04:50 PM
          • DougInAustin
            advice for vinyl roof replacement Model-A closed-cab truck
            Hi all- the vinyl roof on my 1930 Model-A closed-cab truck after about 20 years tore along the front seam where the windshield is, and the wind over time from driving increased the tear so when I drive...
            07-21-2018, 03:26 PM
          • GranTudor
            Installing Top for 1930 Tudor
            I am restoring a 1930 Tudor that had never been in the shape of a complete car when I bought the car 35 years ago. I have rebuilt the car including the top and have just the top material to install. I...
            11-18-2017, 01:53 PM
          • CarlLaFong
            Oil Leak
            Well, after some, in depth, diagnosis, it seems my "oil leak" is, mostly coolant. I can't tell precisely where its coming from. The car has a pressurized system and an overflow added so I'll...
            01-15-2018, 03:06 PM
          • donh
            aluminum top molding for a 30 170B 4 door
            Have tried to bend the molding around the rear corners of the top but can't keep it from twisting. How is it done? Donh
            11-03-2018, 10:48 PM
          • Bill G
            Another 29 Tudor top wood question
            Bill G
            The old wood had a padding of sorts between the wood and the sheet metal in places where the main left and right wood rails contacted the sheet metal roof, and anywhere wood was in direct contact with...
            06-26-2018, 04:20 AM